YOU ARE HERE: HeraldMail HomeCollectionsOpec

Don't blame Bush for high gas prices

January 14, 2006|BY Richard R. Squires

To the editor:

A number of "You Said It" comments indicate the belief that President Bush is responsible for increases in gasoline prices.

The information listed below is taken from current encyclopedias and The Wall Street Journal. Readers of this article can come to their own conclusions regarding the validity of the above comments, i.e., President Bush is responsible for increases in gasoline prices.

Enhanced oil recovery technology can recover roughly 33 percent of original oil from drilling operations. However, this percentage adds extra costs to the oil-extraction process. This supports the view that oil extraction is a high-cost process.

A barrel of crude oil, 42 gallons, can yield almost 21 gallons of gasoline, three gallons of jet fuel and less than four gallons of lubricants. This means that refineries can convert only 28 gallons of usable product from a 42 gallon barrel of crude oil.


This leaves 33 percent of the crude oil, using present technology, of no value to consumers.

Where does worldwide production of crude oil come from? The top 10 crude oil production countries are listed as follows:

Country- Oil production*

Saudi Arabia - 17.3

Russia - 15.1

United States - 12.3

Iran - 8.0

China - 7.1

Mexico - 6.9

Venezuela - 6.5

Norway - 6.4

Iraq (pre-war) - 5.2

Nigeria - 4.8

*Oil production amounts are in quadrillion BTUs (British Thermal Units).

Based on the data in the above table, the United States produces 13.7 percent of the top 10 crude oil production countries. However, when all oil-producing countries are included, only a small fraction of oil is extracted in North America. The U.S. has very little influence on crude oil prices which, in turn, means it has has very little influence on gasoline prices.

The major influence on crude oil prices is OPEC (Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries). The following excerpts are taken from the Wall Street Journal, Dec. 12, 2005. "Crude oil price pushes past $61, fueled by concerns over supply. Crude-oil futures settled above $61 a barrel, up nearly $2."

Futures are what oil price speculators are willing to bid to hold large amounts of crude oil for their own re-sale. In most cases, the purchasers of "futures" will result in significant profit when their holdings are re-sold to the highest bidder. This practice, by itself, increases the price of gasoline. President Bush has no control over these "free enterprise" transactions.

Let's stop for a minute. OPEC, which extracts more than half of worldwide crude oil, meets periodically to determine how much oil its countries will produce. If OPEC decides to cut back on production, the supply of crude oil drops. Virtually in a panic, countries try to outbid other countries to gain access to a limited supply of oil. OPEC profits rise up like a tsunami wave, resulting in a jump in U.S. gasoline prices. President Bush has no control over OPEC and its decisions to do whatever it wishes with its vast oil supply.

From the Wall Street Journal, Dec. 13, 2005; "OPEC indicates it will seek to maintain high oil prices. In a signal that it will seek to keep oil prices high, OPEC decided to continue pumping oil at its current volume, but called a special meeting for next month to review output, with a view to throttling back ahead of the second quarter."

Throttling back means cutting production. Cutting production reduces the supply of oil. Reducing the supply increases the demand. Increased demand increases the price. The increased crude oil price increases the price of gasoline and on and on we go. So, is the increased price of gasoline Bush's fault?

Richard R. Squires

Inwood, W.Va.

The Herald-Mail Articles